You are in the STAGING environment

Document / Publication

  • Do more with your content!Discover PreventionWeb Services
  • Top-down reconstruction and the failure to “build back better” resilient communities after disaster: lessons from the 2009 L’Aquila Italy earthquake
    https://www.preventionweb.net/go/75249

    Email sent!

    An email has been sent to the email addresses provided, with a link to this content.

    Thank you for sharing!

    OK

Top-down reconstruction and the failure to “build back better” resilient communities after disaster: lessons from the 2009 L’Aquila Italy earthquake

Source(s):  University of Groningen

We consider what happened in the initial reconstruction interventions following the 6 April 2009 earthquake in L’Aquila (Italy). Using the disaster risk reduction and resilience paradigm, we discuss the cognitive and interactional failures of top-down approaches, and we analyze the main constraints to enacting inclusive social learning and socially-sustainable transformation and building back better more resilient communities in post-disaster reconstruction. Our evidence comes from participant observation, action anthropology, and analytic auto-ethnography conducted during the reconstruction phase following the L’Aquila earthquake.

Findings were triangulated with document analysis, media analysis, and retrospective interviews conducted in 2013 and 2017. The shift from civil defense to civil protection did not bring any advance in disaster management and development practice in terms of DRR and resilience. The militaristic command-and-control approach, which is still in vogue among civil protection systems, means that local political leaders become the civil protection authorities in a disaster area. 

As in the L’Aquila case, this exacerbates local social and environmental risks and impacts, inhibits local communities from learning, and restricts them from participating in post-disaster interventions. Most previous commentary on disaster recovery and reconstruction following the L’Aquila earthquake has focussed on the top-down approach carried out by the national government and the Italian Department of Civil Protection (DCP). This paper is unique in that it sheds light on how the command and control approach was also implemented by local authority figures and on how this undermined building back better more resilient communities.



Add this content to your collection!

Enter an existing tag to add this content to one or more of your current collections. To start a new collection, enter a new tag below.

See My collections to name and share your collection
Back to search results to find more content to tag

Log in to add your tags
  • Top-down reconstruction and the failure to “build back better” resilient communities after disaster: lessons from the 2009 L’Aquila Italy earthquake
  • Publication date 2020
  • Author(s) Imperiale, Angelo Jonas;Vanclay, Frank
  • Number of pages pp. 541-555
  • ISBN/ISSN ISSN: 0965-3562 DOI 10.1108/DPM-11-2019-0336

Please note:Content is displayed as last posted by a PreventionWeb community member or editor. The views expressed therein are not necessarily those of UNDRR PreventionWeb, or its sponsors. See our terms of use

CONTRIBUTED BY: A PreventionWeb user