• Do more with your content!Discover PreventionWeb Services
  • Earthquake experts condemn 'appalling' Italy manslaughter verdict

    Email sent!

    An email has been sent to the email addresses provided, with a link to this content.

    Thank you for sharing!


Earthquake experts condemn 'appalling' Italy manslaughter verdict

Source(s):  LiveScience, TechMediaNetwork

"Earthquake experts said the scientists had been unfairly scapegoated for failing to predict the unpredictable," writes Stephanie Pappas for LiveScience regarding the manslaughter verdict for six Italian scientists and one government official accused of being too reassuring about the risk of an earthquake prior to the deadly temblor in 2009 in L'Aquila, Italy. An appeal is likely to follow the verdict.

One 1998 study of Italian earthquakes found that only 2 percent of small clusters of quakes predicted a large shock. Another 2010 study found the likelihood of death for citizens in L'Aquila's least-safe buildings still being low enough to be better ameliorated by retrofitting dangerous buildings than evacuating entire towns for indeterminate lengths of time on the slight chance of a quake. "There was a very small chance of that earthquake," said John Vidale, a University of Washington seismologist, told LiveScience. "It didn't make sense for people to evacuate."

Although seismologists agreed that Italy's system for communicating earthquake risk before the trial was imperfect, "the real problem is helping people understand how risk works," Erik Klemetti, a geoscientist at Denison University in Ohio, told LiveScience. "The key to communicating risk about natural disasters, researchers agreed, is to let the public know what scientists don't know," concludes Stephanie Pappas.

Add this content to your collection!

Enter an existing tag to add this content to one or more of your current collections. To start a new collection, enter a new tag below.

See My collections to name and share your collection
Back to search results to find more content to tag

Log in to add your tags
  • Publication date 22 Oct 2012

Please note:Content is displayed as last posted by a PreventionWeb community member or editor. The views expressed therein are not necessarily those of UNISDR PreventionWeb, or its sponsors. See our terms of use