[...]
Avoiding overreliance on regulation to resolve collective action issues
Regulatory mechanisms have become widely discussed approaches for overriding wildfire mitigation inaction on private property. Examples include local defensible space ordinances enforced with fines or liens (e.g. Payson, Arizona), mandatory fees in high-risk wildland–urban interface (WUI) areas to support risk assessments (e.g. Utah House Bill 48, passed in 2025) and requiring adherence to new building or WUI code standards in order to receive a permit to rebuild after wildfire (e.g. select Californian counties and municipalities). While interest in regulation often reveals good intentions, they are rarely a quick fix for large-scale social change because top-down approaches typically do not influence communities’ underlying relationships with wildfire. Regulation is most effective when residents already live in rule-driven community structures (e.g. Homeowners Associations) or areas where reliance on government is commonplace (Winter et al. 2009; Stidham et al. 2014; Steffey et al. 2020). Rural and unincorporated communities are generally unsupportive of top-down approaches that threaten independent lifestyles or require government involvement in private property decision-making (Edgeley et al. 2020; Paveglio et al. 2021). Misalignment of wildfire adaptation approaches with community conditions has long been a source of tension, distrust and inertia. Recent difficulty implementing regulatory mechanisms indicates that their use is not universally effective and may be better suited to small-scale, case-by-case implementation.
Exploring the suitability of regulatory-driven adaptation strategies requires careful introduction of a potenial approach with adequate time for input from affected residents and those responsible for local-level implementation. Providing opportunities to identify limitations or challenges to effective use can support integration of regulations into the existing constellation of adaptation activities already occurring, if appropriate. This might involve inviting local professionals to review implementation plans associated with regulations to proactively address place-based issues and nuance, which often takes the form of listening sessions, workshops, working groups, or advisory councils (e.g. state planning reviews after the Australian Black Saturday Fires; the Deschutes County, Oregon, Wildfire Mitigation Advisory Committee). Screening prospective regulation prior to implementation can support a balance between ambiguity and rigidity that accommodates local nuance while supporting broader consistency. It may also help reduce or remove ambiguity about the conditions under which a policy is implemented prior to widespread communication. Sudden or under-communicated introduction of regulations overrides opportunities for residents to understand why they are being asked to undertake actions, instead only telling them what they must do. These conditions can lead to misinterpretation of policy intent and may introduce or exacerbate conflict. While desirable, coproduction of regulation design and implementation requires longer timeframes and more upfront time investment to streamline implementation on the back end, conflicting with policy-making timelines and voting processes. Furthermore, regulation without provision of resources or capacity to enable compliance can create disparities between those with and without the skills or financial means to engage (Collins 2008; Ellery et al. 2023; Meldrum et al. 2024). Adaptation therefore cannot occur solely through regulation; where regulation is deemed necessary, it should be paired with voluntary, community-driven efforts.
Recognizing the limits of wildfire models in shaping community action
Novel wildfire modeling and related risk mapping of potential WUI fire behavior, risk and event-based scenarios (e.g. how structures might ignite each other, how retrofitting could change fire outcomes) has drawn interest from policy makers, practitioners and community groups (Price et al. 2025; Young et al. 2025; Fig. 1). Underlying these efforts is an assumption that better modelling will lead to better planning, and that model outputs like risk maps will subsequently motivate resident mitigation behaviors. However, it is not clear whether model outputs directly influence risk reduction activities. Modeling efforts have limited value if residents of properties within these higher-resolution studies are unwilling or unable to engage in fuels reduction, structure retrofitting, or other activities the model outputs indicate are beneficial. Additionally, conflict about model outputs between scientists and practitioners tasked with risk assessment or modeling and those living in modeled and mapped places continues to emerge, particularly regarding risk classification of private property (e.g. 2021 Oregon State Bill 762: see Casey 2025). This is particularly common in instances where outputs may be tied to financial consequences such as fees or insurance coverage, indicating limited public trust in wildfire models that may deter proactive risk reduction rather than enable it.
Models and related maps provide limited contributions to community wildfire adaptation if they cannot be merged with rigorous social science or their social limitations are not acknowledged. Evaluative research is needed that determines whether resident or community receipt of model outputs influence mitigative actions or broader behavioral changes and inquires how, if at all, model outputs change wildfire risk planning. Seeking opportunities to conduct this interdisciplinary work in teams with the capacity to navigate iterative rounds that document and respond to user needs (rather than generating an output and retroactively asking for input) can further improve practitioner and community engagement (Cleveland et al. 2024; Emard et al. 2024). The timing and saliency of model or map dissemination relative to community context is also important to consider; not all communities see value in these outputs or are comfortable with their generation and use (Paveglio and Edgeley 2023; Edgeley et al. 2024). Although deeper engagement may require extended timeframes to produce outputs, it can reduce delays and revisions later while encouraging more inclusive and engaged community planning methods, particularly in the context of CWPPs and similar strategic documents where risk maps are currently required.
[...]